If the badge disappears, who checks the landscape?
Updated: 5 hours ago

Voluntary sustainability standards have helped reshape development in England. They have challenged established practice, raised expectations and given developers a way to demonstrate ambition beyond minimum requirements.
Yet accreditation is changing. The closure of a scheme raises questions beyond the loss of a badge: what scrutiny did it provide, what remains available, and who will undertake and fund that work?
The Code for Sustainable Homes was withdrawn in England in 2015, except for legacy cases. Its landscape-related requirements were dispersed across ecology, surface-water management and other categories, rather than forming a comprehensive landscape framework.
Building with Nature was developed by Dr. Gemma Jerome FLI , UWE Bristol and Gloucestershire Wildlife Trust through a Knowledge Transfer Partnership funded by Innovate UK and NERC. Acquired by Sintali in 2024, it has announced the closure of its UK accreditation scheme, stating that the scheme no longer reflects sector needs. Its standards remain available as a best-practice framework.
BREEAM continues. Developed by BRE while it was a government establishment, in collaboration with private-sector interests, it includes dedicated land-use and ecology criteria alongside water, health and transport requirements. New Construction assessment includes longstanding post-construction verification. That verification should be distinguished from continuing evaluation of landscape performance over time.
Building for a Healthy Life supports self-assessment, independent assessment, formal commendation and certification, and post-completion auditing. Its 2026 edition explicitly addresses landscape structure, green and blue infrastructure, tree planting and surface-water management.
These approaches differ in scope and purpose. The wider question is what an assessment demonstrates: the quality of a proposal, its on-site delivery, or its performance over time.
There is a tempting argument that voluntary standards become redundant because they succeed: their ideas enter mainstream practice and policy. But absorbing an ambition into policy is not the same as replacing the independent scrutiny behind it.
Policy only delivers lasting benefits when its requirements are implemented, enforced and supported by long-term care.
1. From innovation to policy
Voluntary standards can act as a testing ground for the industry, particularly where regulation provides limited direction on landscape quality. Independent assessment can help distinguish evidenced commitments from unsupported claims.
Their influence can follow a recognisable pattern:
Innovation: research and practice inform a framework that addresses gaps in existing requirements.
Market recognition: developers, design teams, clients and investors use it to demonstrate ambition and distinguish projects.
Evolution: expectations broaden to address biodiversity, wellbeing, climate adaptation and social value.
Policy uptake: some principles are incorporated into planning policy, procurement requirements, or statutory obligations.
This is progress. It does not mean regulation reproduces the whole framework or its assessment process.
Building regulations, biodiversity net gain and Natural England’s voluntary green infrastructure standards address different requirements. Together, they do not automatically demonstrate that a landscape is accessible, technically workable, successfully established and properly maintained.
England has a statutory target to reach at least 16.5% tree canopy and woodland cover of land area by 31 December 2050. Locally adopted targets, including Gloucestershire’s ambition for at least 20% cover, also provide a benchmark against which development proposals should contribute. Translating these targets into successful places requires site-specific design, delivery and long-term care.
The same applies to sustainable drainage policies. Requiring SuDS does not, by itself, demonstrate that a scheme will manage water effectively or deliver benefits for biodiversity and amenity. Performance depends on coordinated levels, suitable soils, planting, careful construction and funded long-term maintenance.
Some principles addressed by Building with Nature are now reflected more explicitly in policy and national standards. Biodiversity net gain establishes habitat obligations, while England’s updated SuDS standards address water quality, amenity, biodiversity and rainwater reuse. These are substantive requirements, but they do not collectively reproduce the whole BwN framework or its independent assessment and audit. Successful delivery still depends on technical coordination, construction quality and funded long-term care.
When accreditation closes, we need to identify which principles are reflected in policy, which assurance processes remain, where gaps arise and who takes responsibility.
2. Landscape performance depends on systems and relationships
BREEAM addresses several subjects relevant to landscape. The question is how effectively assessment across those subjects demonstrates that the landscape will function as an integrated system.
A 2019 interview-based study by Sewell and Fraser recognised BREEAM’s value in assessing environmental performance while identifying limitations as a broader measure of sustainability. Its recommendation for continuing monitoring after construction is particularly relevant here. The study concerns earlier practice and should not be treated as a verdict on every current BREEAM scheme.
Landscape performance depends on systems and relationships:
Soil condition determines whether vegetation can establish.
Rooting space and water availability influence whether trees reach maturity.
Levels, drainage and planting determine whether a rain garden functions.
Habitat connectivity extends beyond the development boundary.
Access, shade, seating and sensory conditions influence whether people can use a space.
A project team can assemble evidence against individual criteria while missing weaknesses between them. The assessment needs to examine those relationships, along with the responsibilities and resources required to sustain them.
3. Planning ambition meets technical delivery
The gap between environmental ambition and delivery becomes expensive when essential coordination happens too late.
Planning applications and conditions can resolve important technical matters. Consent alone, however, does not demonstrate that utility conflicts, soil suitability, drainage levels, construction sequencing and maintenance access have all been successfully coordinated or implemented.
Common pressure points include:
Late technical coordination: trees, habitats and drainage features compete with infrastructure that was insufficiently resolved earlier.
Procurement and value engineering: substitutions or reductions weaken the conditions on which the original design depended.
Construction quality: compaction, unsuitable imported soils and poor installation undermine an otherwise sound proposal.
Development timescales: phased delivery, ownership changes and funding pressures interrupt continuity.
Establishment and management: living systems need skilled care beyond practical completion.
Frameworks need to accommodate these realities. Clients also need to commission the expertise required to resolve them.
A landscape accreditation has limited value if its recommendations never reach the specification, construction programme or maintenance contract.
4. Review needs to follow the project
Three distinct tasks need attention:
Design assessment: are the proposals credible, coordinated and appropriate to the site?
Completion verification: has the assessed design been delivered, and have subsequent changes been reviewed?
Ongoing evaluation: is the landscape establishing and performing, and are failures being corrected?
Independent assessment, peer review and certification can contribute in different ways. None should be assumed to cover all three tasks without examining the scheme’s actual requirements.
Building for a Healthy Life provides routes for independent assessment and post-completion auditing. The practical question is how consistently those routes are commissioned and how findings lead to improvements. A positive design assessment provides evidence about a proposal; demonstrating health and wellbeing benefits also requires attention to the place that is built and experienced.
Statutory requirements have legal force, and planning authorities have enforcement powers. Their effectiveness nevertheless depends on clear responsibilities and sufficient capacity to inspect, monitor and secure corrective action.
Local planning authorities have a central role in checking that approved landscape requirements are delivered and taking enforcement action where necessary. But this depends on access to landscape expertise, officer time and resources for inspection and follow-up. Embedding higher expectations in policy cannot replace that capacity. If we increasingly rely on planning requirements to secure landscape quality, we must also fund the people who scrutinise proposals, check delivery and pursue failures.
For biodiversity net gain, off-site gains and significant on-site habitat enhancements must be maintained for at least 30 years. These commitments require effective oversight through changes in ownership and management.
Who checks whether a SuDS basin functions five years later? Who reviews habitat condition? Who acts when management undermines the approved scheme? Those responsibilities need to be agreed and funded, whether assurance comes through accreditation, planning requirements, contractual obligations or estate management.
5. Landscape expertise needs continuity
Landscape architects connect strategic ambition with site conditions, technical design, construction and long-term care. That expertise needs to remain involved throughout the project, working with ecologists, engineers, architects, contractors and asset managers.
In the public sector, landscape specialists help scrutinise proposals, coordinate requirements and establish workable conditions and management expectations. In the private sector, they help clients resolve constraints early, protect specifications and plan realistic establishment and maintenance. Continued involvement through construction and management supports inspection, corrective work and performance evaluation.
This requires fees, programmes and appointments that allow the work to happen.
At Landsmith Associates, connecting policy, site conditions and long-term care is central to our work. Strategic objectives need to inform the practical decisions that shape construction, everyday management and the experience of people using a place.
Voluntary standards have helped raise expectations. When an accreditation route closes, the response should identify the scrutiny it provided and make an explicit decision about how that work will continue. Policy, inspection, technical expertise and skilled maintenance each have a role.
If the badge disappears, who checks that the promises survive construction and continue to deliver over time?
References
Code for Sustainable Homes: withdrawal and legacy arrangements.
UWE Bristol: development of Building with Nature and its funding.
Building with Nature: UK accreditation closure announcement.
England’s tree canopy and woodland cover target delivery plan.
Sewell, J. and Fraser, D. (2019), A Study of the Effectiveness of BREEAM as an Assessment Tool for Sustainability by Interview of Practitioners.



